Trouble in paradise: 7 reality stars who were edited out of their seasons
Trouble in paradise: 7 reality stars who were edited out of their seasons
Randall ColburnWed, April 8, 2026 at 9:00 PM UTC
0
Pete Hunziker on 'Below Deck Mediterranean'; Dakota Mortensen on 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives'; Dee Nguyen on 'The Challenge'Credit: Karolina Wojtasik/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty; Disney/Fred Hayes; Riccardo Giardina/MTV
The question of how to deal with "problematic" celebrities has been raised again and again in recent years. And with social media amplifying our ever-evolving thoughts, beliefs, and biases, more public figures are being called to account for past statements.
This has been particularly evident in the realm of reality TV, which often hosts people who are new to the public eye. How a personality, producer, or network handles problematic behaviors, especially as it relates to a show's ongoing production, is an imperfect science. Some confront the issue head on while others try to sweep it away, lest the rest of the cast and crew suffer.
Taylor Frankie Paul of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, for example, saw her already-filmed season of The Bachelorette yanked from ABC's schedule after video emerged of a 2023 fight between the MomTok star and her ex, Dakota Mortensen, surfaced online. But the reaction isn't always that severe; sometimes a show is salvaged by strategically editing the offending personality.
Below, we unpack several such moments in reality TV history.
Dakota Mortensen (Vanderpump Villa)
Dakota Mortensen and Taylor Frankie Paul on 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives'Credit: Fred Hayes/Disney
The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star Taylor Frankie Paul was always a risky choice to be The Bachelorette, especially considering her volatile relationship with Dakota Mortensen, the father of her son Ever. Now, Mortensen is also seeing his future TV appearances impacted by domestic assault allegations involving the couple. In April 2026, Entertainment Weekly learned that Mortensen would be edited out of the upcoming season of Vanderpump Villa.
The news comes on the heels of allegations of domestic assault that were "made in both directions" by Paul and Mortensen, according to the Draper City Police Department. It also follows Paul's season of The Bachelorette, which was canceled days ahead of its release once video emerged of a 2023 fight between the pair.
At the time, Paul was charged with misdemeanor assault, criminal mischief, and commission of domestic violence in the presence of a child. She was placed on probation after pleading guilty to the aggravated assault charge. The other charges were dismissed.
Mortensen's appearance on Vanderpump Villa, a Hulu reality series centering on the staffers of international vacation spots overseen by Lisa Vanderpump, was heavily teased in season 4 of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. He attended the villa with other members of "DadTok," the husbands of the Mormon Wives cast.
A representative for Mortensen did not respond to Entertainment Weekly's request for comment.
Pete Hunziker (Below Deck Mediterranean)
Peter Hunziker in 'Below Deck Mediterranean' season 5Credit: Karolina Wojtasik/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty
Peter Hunziker quickly made waves as a deckhand on season 5 of Below Deck Mediterranean, which aired in the summer of 2020. He flaunted an ego and irritated bosun Malia White, his boss, by repeatedly referring her to "sweetheart" and other pet names.
After just three episodes had aired, Bravo shared a statement saying Hunziker had been "terminated for his racist posts" and that the season would be edited to "minimize his appearance for subsequent episodes."
This was certainly true, and likely jarring for casual viewers unaware of the news. Throughout the season's back half, Peter appears only briefly in the backgrounds and edges of shots.
Six weeks after his firing, Peter shared an apology to his Instagram account. "A little over 3 months ago someone sent me a meme on social media and I thoughtlessly reposted it," he said (via PEOPLE). "I now realize how painful the imagery and symbolism is and, upon deeper consideration, I realize that the implicit bias that exists in the brief text written in the meme is offensive."
He continued, "To all those I have hurt and offended please know that I am genuinely sorry. I have always fully supported equal rights and equal opportunities for ALL people."
Dee Nguyen (The Challenge)
Dee Nguyen in 'The Challenge' season 35Credit: Riccardo Giardina/MTV
Dee Nguyen joined The Challenge in season 33 of the MTV competition series after starring on the Jersey Shore spinoff Geordie Shore. After solid debut, the Australian athlete went on to win the following season alongside Chris "CT" Tamburello, Jordan Wiseley, and Rogan O'Connor.
It looked as if she'd become a Challenge regular, but her appearance on season 35 would be her last. In June 2020, a few months after the season's April debut, MTV announced that it had "severed ties" with Nguyen, who was mostly edited out of the remaining episodes until her elimination in July.
Nguyen's firing was due to insensitive posts she made regarding the Black Lives Matter movement in the aftermath of George Floyd's murder at the hands of a police officer on May 25, 2020.
Much of the criticism she received was in response to a now-deleted tweet in which she said, "IDK why some of you think I’m anti-BLM. I’ve been saying that since the day I lost my virginity.”
Nguyen was criticized by several of her Challenge costars, including Bayleigh Dayton, who said she was "disgusted and disappointed" by her remarks.
Nguyen initially fired back, alleging her critics were "creating a cancel culture," but later apologized. "I am sorry for the insensitive tweet I posted earlier," she said. "I was being defensive and not speaking from my heart. But there’s no excuse."
Advertisement
Sarah Shafi (Masterchef UK)
Sarah Shafi on 'Good Morning Britain' on Aug. 4, 2025Credit: Ken McKay/ITV/Shutterstock
Sarah Shafi, a contestant on Masterchef UK in 2025, was edited out of the show's 21st season amid allegations of misconduct made against hosts Gregg Wallace and John Torode.
The BBC decided to air the season, which had already filmed, because it "is the right thing to do for these cooks who have given so much to the process."
Shafi, on the other hand, disagreed. As she said in interviews at the time, she took issue not with her involvement in the season, but it being aired at all.
“I didn’t say edit me out,” she told The Guardian. “I said: ‘Axe the show, don’t air the show. I’m asking you not to air the show.’ Prominent figures have been abusing their power. What message does that send out to women?"
Wallace was accused of using inappropriate sexual language and unwanted physical contact. He was let go from the cooking competition series after Banijay, the show's producer, "substantiated 45 allegations made against him." He responded by saying he was “deeply sorry for any distress caused."
Torode, meanwhile, was accused of using "an extremely offensive racist term" in the workplace during an incident the host doesn't recall happening. After an internal investigation substantiated the allegation, it was decided that his contract would not be renewed.
“For me, it’s about the enabling environment. It’s that complicity," Shafi continued. "Those individual powerful men do not [act] in isolation. There is an enabling environment, turning a blind eye … It’s about years of these institutions not being accountable.”
In lieu of not airing the season, the BBC chose to edit her out of it. The BBC reported that a second contestant had also asked to be removed from the season.
Kelly Shinn (Survivor: Nicaragua)
Kelly Shinn on 'Survivor: Nicaragua'Credit: Monty Brinton/CBS via Getty
Kelly Shinn competed on Survivor: Nicaragua, the show's 21st season, but you'd be forgiven for not remembering her. Her absence in the final edit of the season led to what's now known as the "purple edit," a phrase for someone who's barely featured on the long-running survival competition.
Speaking with EW following her departure, Shinn said that "CBS did themselves a disservice by giving me the edit they did."
She also claimed she was edited deceptively in the season's finale. "During the finale episode, they made it look like I was talking with one person when in fact it was directed at someone completely different," she told us. "That was disappointing. I think you get the drift — not thrilled about the edit I was given, but I've also enjoyed proving myself to others. I am not what CBS tried to make me look like, and for that I am very proud!"
So, why was Shinn given such an unflattering edit? Well, it might have something to do with the fact that she quit the show after 28 days in the wilderness. And host Jeff Probst has never been shy about how he feels about quitters. "I can tell you that personally I don’t see a spot on the jury for quitters," he told us in 2015.
But Shinn doesn't regret her decision, which she explained in a postmortem with PEOPLE. "I was so physically ill," Shinn said. "I tried to figure out if my body could handle any more and I didn’t think it could."
Yulissa Escobar and Cierra Ortega (Love Island USA)
Yulissa Escobar and Cierra Ortega on 'Love Island USA'Credit: Ben Symons/PEACOCK (2)
While Yulissa Escobar and Cierra Ortega weren't exactly edited out of their seasons, they were absent from Love Island USA season 7 after both were criticized for past uses of racial slurs. Since the reality dating show is filmed in real time, their instant exits served to completely remove them from the unfolding action.
Escobar was ejected just two episodes into the season after TMZ published a clip of her using the N-word during past appearances on podcasts. Representatives for the show never confirmed to EW that the use of the slur was the reason for her exit, and her departure was addressed on the series with a terse announcement that "Yulissa has left the villa."
She later apologized in a social media statement, owning up to her use of the slur. "I used it ignorantly, not fully understanding the weight, history, or pain behind it. I wasn't trying to be offensive or harmful, but I recognize now that intention doesn't excuse impact. And the impact of that word is real. It's tied to generations of trauma, and it is not mine to use."
Ortega, meanwhile, was removed from the villa 26 days into filming. This time, fans were told she left due to a "personal situation." But it followed the resurfacing of old social media posts in which she used a racial slur.
She apologized for using the slur in the aftermath of her exit. "I take accountability for using the word, but I do want it to be known that I genuinely had no idea that it was a slur," she wrote in an apology on social media.
Ortega also credits the controversy with her departure from the villa. "I think that this is something that deserved punishment, and the punishment has absolutely been received," she said.
Get your daily dose of entertainment news, celebrity updates, and what to watch with our EW Dispatch newsletter.
on Entertainment Weekly
Source: “AOL Entertainment”
